Property Tax Bombshell - 54% Increase in Land Value
I'm surprised that no one else has mentioned this on the blog yet, but I nearly fell out of my chair when I received my tax bill. When my wife went in to the assessors office for an explanation, she was told something to the effect that the Fox Hill Street land values had increased everyone's land value in the town. I am curious to know if anyone else has more information on this subject. However, the following comes to mind.
First, when I went in to the assessors office last year to discuss my tax bill and how high it was, they said the then current depressed market prices would not be reflected on the bills until the following year (i.e. now). That's because the assessments are based on sales from the previous years' sales. This years' bill is supposedly based on land values in 2007. I haven't gone into any sort of hard research on this yet, but my recollection is that property values were flat or down from 2006 to 2007 and certainly went down in 2008. In fact, I bet that the Fox Hill sales substantially and unreasonably skewed the 2007 figures because the only thing that people were purchasing in Westwood that year was high end new-to-the-market property. No one with any older inventory could sell anything at any reasonable value.
Second, the Fox Hill values should have no effect on my neighborhood, or if anything, cause the value to go down. The shiny new neighborhood with the cobblestone walks, stone wall entrance, no overhead wires, faux gas lamps and some views of Boston will certainly draw potential buyers away from my shabby old neighborhood with homes built in the early 70s with it's richly pot-holed streets and no sidewalks to get you anywhere you want to go. No to mention that my neighborhood is far removed from Fox Hill Street.
I would love to hear from anyone who might know a thing or two about how all of this works because I certainly don't have the ability to keep paying the old rates, let alone the new.
Comments
probably varies by neighborhood
When we first moved to our house at the Islington end of Gay Street in 2005, the assessments rapidly "corrected" from the previous owner's purchase price. Since then it has been relatively flat: 0% in FY2008 and 1% for the FY2009 assessment. The assessed value is still different from market value or appraisal value--both of which I hope are higher--so personally, I'm not complaining too much.
We moved back to Massachusetts from California in 2002...in CA, the tax assessment is based on the last purchase price. Thanks Proposition 2. So if you are a long-time owner, you may be sitting in a million dollar bungalow paying little or no taxes; then a young couple buys it and immediately gets hit with a reassessment at the price they paid. I think the system here is designed to be a bit more fair, but "fair to whom" is always the question...
property tax variables and assessments
It's highly unusual that a property tax valuation would increase by such a large percentage over the course of a single year and certainly deserving of further investigation. I would request from the assessors office a 5 year historical listing of comparable property valuations in your neighborhood. You may find that your property had been undervalued until the current assessment.
what is the appeals/review process?
Thanks John,
I didn't mean to give the impression that b/c my prop tax didn't go up...no problem...but it would be good to hear from the town:
Here is a link to the town website with information on assessments.
Finally, for those who have not discovered it yet, go to http://zillow.com and you can see what they estimate the value of your (and your neighbors') property to be. But remember...the only prices that really matter are: 1) the price a real buyer pays you and 2) what the town assesses your property for, resulting in your tax bill. Zillow can be exciting and depressing.
FY2009 Property Assessments
The town released the FY2009 Property Assessments. It's public information and I would suggest others to read through the increases and decreases. Yes there were some neighborhoods that had a decrease!
Click for PDF of assessments
You'd be surprised by the assessments.
/JL